Business Valuation: How to Determine What Your Business Is Really Worth

Quick Summary

In practice, a company is worth what a qualified buyer will pay for the cash it is expected to produce, discounted for the risk that the cash will not keep coming in. We weigh earnings, measured as SDE or EBITDA, against what comparable companies have actually sold for and the intangibles that never appear on a balance sheet, such as loyal customers, sound systems and a good name. The less the business depends on you, on one large customer or on a single supplier, the higher the number tends to go, although the asking price still has to fit financing a buyer can realistically get.

Most owners first ask what their company is worth shortly before they start thinking about a sale, and a business valuation is how that question gets a real answer. The same question also comes up when partners split, when a lender wants support for a loan or when an estate plan needs a figure, and in every case the answer combines numbers with a fair amount of judgment.

We have valued and sold privately held Arizona companies at Strategic Business Brokers Group for more than 35 years, and each of those conversations begins in confidence. What follows is how we approach the question, what tends to move the number and what you can start doing about it now.

What Is a Business Worth?

Courts and the Internal Revenue Service describe fair market value as the price at which property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, when neither is forced to act and both know the relevant facts. It is a useful definition, and it rewards a second reading.

The trouble is that real sales rarely look like that. Owners sell because of health, burnout or a partner dispute, buyers fall in love with a business or feel pressure to close before a loan approval expires, and emotion and sentiment show up in almost every negotiation we handle. Strictly speaking, the definition does not even require a sale to happen, which is fitting, since few real transactions would meet all of its conditions.

Tangible vs. Intangible Assets

Every privately held company is made up of tangible and intangible assets. The tangible side, meaning fixtures, equipment and leasehold improvements, is what a buyer sees first on a tour, and it often carries more weight in their thinking than it should. A clean, well-kept shop does make a strong impression whatever a buyer says out loud, and lenders find physical assets much easier to finance than anything they cannot touch.

Still, a good buyer looks past the equipment to what actually produces the profit. In many companies today the physical assets play only a small part, and the real value sits in the company’s reputation with customers and within its industry, its customer lists, the quality of its product or service, its standing with vendors and suppliers, and the strength of its technology and systems. Those factors frequently add far more to the price than a lot full of trucks.

Even so, many buyers hesitate to pay the same price for the same cash flow when a business owns little equipment, because they feel more comfortable buying something they can see. Showing those buyers how the hidden assets keep the cash flow steady is a large part of the work a broker does on a service business.

Purpose changes the answer as well. A figure prepared for an estate or gift tax filing follows strict IRS rules, while a figure prepared for a sale estimates what buyers will pay in the current market, so the same company can carry two different numbers and both can be correct.

Key Factors That Influence Business Value

Two companies with identical profits can sell for very different prices, and the reasons usually start with the industry and whether it is growing or shrinking. Location matters next, including local demand, wage levels and the strength of the regional economy.

After that, buyers look at people, products and customers. They want to know whether the managers will stay, whether the products are current or hard to copy, and how concentrated the revenue is, because if one account makes up a third of your sales every buyer will ask what happens if it leaves, and the same goes for relying on a single supplier. Recurring revenue, such as service contracts that renew every year, usually counts for more than a yard full of equipment.

Tip: The fewer dependencies your business has, whether on you, on one customer or on one supplier, the more valuable it tends to become.

Simplifying the Valuation Process

We usually begin with cash flow. Seller’s discretionary earnings, or SDE, adds the owner’s salary, benefits and any one-time or personal expenses back to net profit and fits most owner-run companies, while larger firms with management in place are measured on EBITDA, which stands for earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization.

From there the questions get softer. Are the earnings real, will they hold up once you step away, and can every figure be tied back to a tax return or bank statement? A buyer’s accountant will ask all three, so it pays to have the answers ready before anyone else looks.

To get started, gather three years of profit and loss statements and tax returns that agree with each other, a list of add-backs with supporting documents, your equipment list and lease, a summary of your largest customers and suppliers, and copies of key contracts and licenses, since any missing piece slows the process down.

Business Valuation Methods

Appraisers rely on three main approaches and often blend them. The asset-based approach adds up the assets and subtracts the debts, which suits equipment-heavy companies and usually sets a floor when earnings are weak. The market approach compares your company with recent sales of similar businesses, normally as a multiple of SDE or EBITDA, and the income approach projects future cash flow and discounts it back to today’s dollars at the return a buyer would want for the risk.

Because each method answers a slightly different question, you should expect a range rather than one perfect number. Our article on the rule of thumb for selling a business explains why industry shortcuts are only a starting point.

Pricing vs. Valuation: What’s the Difference?

A valuation produces a range, while the price is what you finally agree to, and that depends on the deal structure, the financing and how much competition there is among buyers.

Suppose one buyer bids higher but wants you to carry a large note for several years, and another bids a little lower but pays almost entirely in cash at closing. The larger number is not automatically the better deal, although a modest amount of seller financing can raise the price a buyer will accept, because it shows you believe in the business.

Terms also hide in less obvious places, such as who keeps the receivables, whether inventory is included in the price or added on top, and whether you will stay on for a few months and be paid for it. Each of those moves real money, which is why we read the entire term sheet rather than only the headline figure.

Competition matters as well. Having several serious buyers at the table at the same time tends to improve your terms, while a single buyer usually means a price near the low end of the range.

How to Prepare for a Valuation

Start by cleaning up the books, and then make sure recurring revenue and long-term contracts are easy to see, because buyers pay more for income they can count on.

It also helps to make yourself less necessary by training managers, writing down how the work gets done and keeping customers and vendors close. Gather your records of intellectual property, licenses and contracts now rather than scrambling for them during due diligence.

Fix what you can before anyone takes a close look. A dated website, a stack of overdue receivables or a lease with eight months left will not sink a sale by itself, but each one gives a buyer an easy reason to shave the price, and small repairs made early cost less than discounts given later.

Talk to our brokers about our valuation services to see what your company could be worth in today’s market, or read how we help owners sell a business in Arizona.

Common Valuation Mistakes to Avoid

Overrating goodwill tops the list, since buyers pay for goodwill only when it shows up in cash flow, and forgetting about debt comes a close second, because loans, equipment leases and payables all come out of your proceeds at closing.

Out-of-date numbers cause problems too, and so do the wrong benchmarks, such as borrowing a multiple from another industry or from a much larger company. A do-it-yourself valuation tends to fail for a simpler reason: owners value the years they have put in, but buyers pay for what the business will earn going forward.

If you would like a realistic, confidential read on what your company is worth, contact us or request a free business valuation to get started.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does a valuation cost?

The cost depends on the size of the company and the purpose of the valuation. A broker’s opinion of value prepared for a sale is usually far less expensive than a certified appraisal for court or tax use, and Strategic Business Brokers Group gives owners who are considering a sale a free valuation.

Every two to three years is a sensible rhythm, and sooner after a major change such as winning a large contract, losing a key customer or a partner leaving, since regular checks show whether you are moving toward your exit goals.

Not automatically, because a buyer will run their own numbers and their lender may order a separate appraisal. A well-documented valuation narrows the gap, though, because it shows exactly how each figure was reached.